From Iraq to Brexit: Failing to learn the lessons

“As we endure the very early stages of the Brexit vote, it is worth considering the further negative consequences of this unplanned odyssey.”

Hide

Perhaps it is fitting that the Chilcot Report should be published so close to the Brexit Vote, thus linking the two most damaging British foreign policy decisions of living memory. But these events are linked by more than timing. Both decisions’ split the country; in March 2003 it was 53% for 39% against, while Brexit was 51.8 to 48.2 of those that voted. More importantly both decisions were fuelled by dissatisfaction with the status quo and a belief that alternative, better futures were possible. Whether these possible futures were likely or not, played less of a role in both decisions. Over Iraq policy planning took the form of an approach to threat assessment which predicted calamitous “Superterrorism” where Saddam Hussain would arm terrorists with Weapons of Mass Destruction if he was not stopped. On the one hand with forecasts that his decapitation would lead to the flowering of democracy in Iraq, (the most secular and educated Arab population in the region) and lead to the development of peace and prosperity for the entire Middle East on the other. This curious mix of worst case threat assessment for inaction and best case predictions of the consequence of action characterised the overconfidence of the Blair Government. Only later would he admit that “For sure, we underestimated profoundly the forces that were at work in the region.” In 2003 there was a refusal to accept the possibility that this action could make things worse and instead a desire to impose a western order, to “take back control”, of an unravelling Middle East.

Chilcot will also criticise the wilful desire to ignore experts, from the diplomatic corps and the academic community, both of whom warned that this action was likely to precipitate events that would spiral out of control in Iraq and beyond. That same contempt for experts was also evident amongst the leave campaign, most memorably in Michael Gove’s statement that “I think the people have of this country have had enough of experts from organisations with acronyms saying that they know what is best and getting it consistently wrong.” In 2003 as in 2016 the willingness to dismiss the advice of those who were in a position to advise against precipitous and damaging consequences led to a series of actions damaging to the UK’s standing in the world and those who it interacts with. The willingness to embrace simplistic solutions to complex problems is a feature of both crises. Rather than having learned the lessons of Iraq, however, that episode in British history has played into the EU debate by further undermining trust in the wisdom of establishment voices and the veracity of political elites. The financial crisis of 2008 eroded their standing further.

While most attention will no doubt focus on Chilcot’s deliberations on the decision to go to war, the Commission has also considered other aspects of the UK’s role in Iraq 2003-2009, such as the intelligence advice on WMD, the legality of the invasion, how well prepared the UK was for the military action and why the operation went so badly wrong.

As we endure the very early stages of the Brexit vote, it is worth considering the further negative consequences of this unplanned odyssey. In Iraq the damage done to that country and the reputation of the UK on the world stage were made worse by a failure to realise and reverse the initial foreign policy error. With Brexit the opportunity to reverse track, however difficult, it is a chance that should not be missed. The alternative is a version of Chilcot mark two, some years from now, on how the UK could possibly have blundered so badly again.

You can also read Dr Jamie Gaskarth's perspective The Chilcot Report: Lessons to be learnt

Have your say...

Feedback
  • 88952634
    External
    1. At 10:44AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    2. At 10:44AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    3. At 10:45AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    4. At 10:45AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    5. At 10:45AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    6. At 10:45AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    7. At 10:45AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    8. At 10:45AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    9. At 10:45AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    10. At 10:45AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    11. At 10:45AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    12. At 10:45AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    13. At 10:45AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    14. At 10:46AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    15. At 10:46AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    16. At 10:46AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    17. At 10:46AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    18. At 10:46AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    19. At 10:46AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    20. At 10:46AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    21. At 10:46AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    22. At 10:46AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634'`"(
    External
    23. At 10:46AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634-0
    External
    24. At 10:47AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634s3
    External
    25. At 10:47AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634'+'
    External
    26. At 10:47AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634'
    External
    27. At 10:47AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634'||'
    External
    28. At 10:47AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634'
    External
    29. At 10:47AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    30. At 10:48AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    31. At 10:48AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    32. At 10:48AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    33. At 10:48AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    34. At 10:48AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    35. At 10:48AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    36. At 10:48AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    37. At 10:48AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    38. At 10:48AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    39. At 10:48AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    40. At 10:49AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    41. At 10:49AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    42. At 10:49AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    43. At 10:49AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    44. At 10:49AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    45. At 10:49AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    46. At 10:49AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    47. At 10:49AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    48. At 10:49AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    49. At 10:49AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    50. At 10:49AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    51. At 10:49AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    52. At 10:49AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    53. At 10:49AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    54. At 10:50AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    55. At 10:50AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    56. At 10:50AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    57. At 10:50AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634

  • 88952634
    External
    58. At 10:50AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634'`"(

  • 88952634
    External
    59. At 10:50AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634-0

  • 88952634
    External
    60. At 10:50AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634s3

  • 88952634
    External
    61. At 10:50AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634'+'

  • 88952634
    External
    62. At 10:50AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634'

  • 88952634
    External
    63. At 10:50AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634'||'

  • 88952634
    External
    64. At 10:50AM on 11 December 2016, wrote

    88952634'

Add Your Feedback