Coronavirus update

Important information:
All on-campus visits and events are cancelled or postponed until further notice. Virtual events will be running as normal unless otherwise stated.  For the latest updates visit our coronavirus information page. Please note that some of our on campus events may be replaced by virtual events - please check with the event organiser listed against each event.

Human dignity: a useful concept?

Location
ERI Building - Room 149 (1st Floor)
Dates
Monday 20 January 2014 (16:15-18:00)
Contact

Dr Darragh Byrne (email: d.byrne@bham.ac.uk)

Philosophy Society 2013-2014

 

Anne Phillips (London School of Economics)

 

Human Dignity: a Useful Concept?

 

Abstract:

Human dignity has come to figure as an important reference point for human rights, and it is widely argued - in both legal and political theory -  that one cannot talk of human rights without relying in some way on a conception of human dignity. In other quarters, however, human dignity is subject to robust denunciations: it is regarded as a 'useless' concept, a 'stupid' concept, a nebulous or empty notion that is inappropriately deployed to block practices that fully agentic humans have agreed to. In this paper I make a third argument. I argue that the notion of human dignity is indeed problematic, because it draws on overly substantive accounts of 'the human' and what it is to live a fully human life. Though I share with the 'dignitarians' the view that there is more at stake in many issues than whether or not the individuals involved have freely agreed, I argue that  this can be adequately captured in the notion of equality. Dignity is often just another way of saying equality. When it isn't - when it edges into problematically substantive notions of what it is to be human - it edges into something we would do better to avoid.

Culture and collections

Schools, institutes and departments

Services and facilities