David Hunt

David Hunt

Department of Philosophy
Doctoral researcher

Contact details

Address
ERI Building
University of Birmingham
Edgbaston
Birmingham
B15 2TT
UK

  • PhD title: Moral relativism and moral error theory
  • Supervisor: Jussi Suikkanen

Biography

In terms of background, I have mostly been involved in extreme music as a singer, and continue to do this alongside my PhD. Currently I am a member of both Anaal Nathrakh and Benediction. I've released a number of albums with several bands, many of which chart an extended engagement with various forms of nihilism.

Research

My PhD is an attempt to take one of the less favoured positions in metaethics, moral relativism, and defend it particularly against one of the more popular and active schools of thought, moral error theory.

Among the various intuitions which people have about ethics and metaethics, some degree of moral relativism is quite common. Yet while there are academic philosophers who defend versions of it, to quote the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 'moral relativism has the unusual distinction - both within philosophy and outside it - of being attributed to others, almost always as a criticism, far more often than it is explicitly professed by anyone.' This is not without reason, as there are some very tricky questions raised by moral relativism, particularly about normativity. I aim to contribute to the efforts to answer those questions.

Moral error theory, on the other hand, involves the counterintuitive thesis that there are no objective values, and therefore all moral judgments are systematically false. Despite sounding odd to the layman, moral error theory has been intensively debated over the past few years, and has been powerfully defended by a number of illustrious thinkers. I aim to show how moral relativism and moral error theory can both be used in a novel way to describe moral practise as it currently is, and how it should be conceived of in the future.

This project was motivated by preoccupations with the objectivity of morality and nihilism. In my Masters dissertation, I argued against Divine Command Theory, and now I am interested in arguing against the objectivity of moral values in general. Thus I see a rejuvenated form of moral relativism as a post-nihilist possibility for making sense of a world of devoid of 'thou shalt', while retaining a genuinely moral dimension in human life.

For more information, please contact me via email.