Educational Gain: Beyond the rhetoric

 

Prem Kumar & Clare Ray


The point of a university education has always been to help students reach their full potential and become well-rounded individuals prepared to make meaningful contributions to their communities and the world. But how do we achieve that if, in the words of Sonal Minocha, our present undergraduate programmes are often ‘dominated with coping with the present and, at worst, the past’. Do we believe that by measuring improvement in highly predictable assessments, we are also determining the acquisition of complex graduate outcomes and attributes? This is, at best, a confusion of simultaneity with causality. In other words, might it be that our best students succeed despite us, whilst our weakest students fail because of us? With a falling demand for university places among school-leavers and a rapidly increasing demand for industrial and professional apprenticeships coupled to the dropping of any requirement of degree classes or even A-level results from the application forms of several significant employers, has there ever been a more critical time for us to reappraise our mission.

In 1886, Friedrich Nietzsche  stated that ‘Ultimately, it is the desire, not the desired, that we love’ and it is our belief that we should look to (re)engender in our students a desire for learning and adaptability through long-lasting changes in behaviour based upon experience, rather than the desired acquisition of a degree qualification that can simply reward a lack of imagination. Thus, if you are concerned that your students are producing answers that may be indistinguishable from AI-generated ones then you are simply asking the wrong questions. Our conjecture is that measures of desire and adaptability will better determine ‘educational gain’ but, more importantly, will future-proof ‘career-readiness’ in these exciting and data-rich but increasingly uncertain and highly unpredictable AI-times. This interactive, end-of-conference, session will be used to help summarise and distil the key ideas from the day by exploring the concept of what a University education should confer upon a learner and how or even whether that is measurable. The future requires us and our students to be able to undertake rapid learning, unlearning and adaptation. Are we ready? 

 

Clare Ray is a Reader in Widening Participation in Biomedical Education and is the College of Medical and Dental Sciences lead for Outreach and Widening Participation. She leads a range of successful schemes and activities that promote the participation, success and progression of underrepresented groups in Higher Education and Chairs the National Medical Schools Widening Participation Forum. In recognition of this work received the Joseph Chamberlain Award for Educational Advancement, one of four Founders’ Awards made by the University in July 2022. Clare is a cardiovascular and respiratory physiologist and a Principal Fellow of the Higher Education Academy (PFHEA), with teaching responsibilities across many of the Institute of Clinical Sciences’ undergraduate programmes.

 

Clare Ray

 

 

Prem Kumar

Prem Kumar is an Emeritus Professor. 

His research interests are in the field of chemoreception, with a particular emphasis on carotid body and chemotransduction mechanisms in health and disease and in the reflex responses to hypoxia and changes in blood glucose concentrations. He is a key member of the Birmingham Arterial Chemoreceptor and Hypoxia Group.

Between 2012 and 2018 Professor Kumar was the Director of Education for the College of Medical and Dental Sciences and between 2015 and 2021 was the inaugural Director of the Institute of Clinical Sciences. Between 2019 and 2021 he led on the Academic Development Programme workstream that identified the training needs of new academics as part of the Birmingham Academic Career Framework.