Key findings from Story Choices

In this Literacy Research Network seminar Professor Julia Carroll discusses key findings from a recent randomised controlled trial, the Story Choices Trial
    • Date
      Friday, 27 November 2026 (14:00 - 15:00) (UK)
    • Format
      Online and in person
    • Location
      Room 423B, 4th Floor, Education Building, University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham, B15 2TT

It is well established that interactive storybook reading (sometimes called dialogic reading) is an effective approach to improving oral language in preschool children. However, there is little evidence around which approach to planning group storybook reading sessions is most effective.

This trial compared two approaches: a planned approach in which educators planned the books they would use and the prompts and vocabulary they would focus on, and a child-led approach in which children could choose which book they heard and interactions were led by child interest.

Eighty-two preschool settings took part and were randomised to one of the two approaches. They were asked to use the approach at least three times a week for twelve weeks.

Children in the child-led approach showed slightly higher levels of progress in language measures than those in the planned approach. This finding was contrary to our hypotheses, which were that planning language interactions would be most effective.

There are a few possible reasons behind this finding. Educator feedback indicated that children in the child-led condition tended to be more engaged and had opportunities to discuss their views around books. In addition, session records indicated that settings in the planned approach tended to repeat books more often than those in the child-led approach.

The findings have interesting implications for the role of engagement and agency in improving oral language.

  • It is open to all
  • This is a hybrid event, however in-person attendance is encouraged, but an online link will also be provided
  • Registration is essential to let us know if you will be attending in-person or online and to receive the online link.

To join the Literacy Research Network and find out about future seminars, please contact Helen Breadmore.

Location

Address
Room 423B4th FloorEducation BuildingUniversity of BirminghamEdgbastonBirminghamB15 2TT