Lessons from COVID-19 on the economics of obesity: an urgent call for action

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the University of Birmingham

“COVID-19 has highlighted the urgency of dealing with obesity as no longer a ‘cosmetic condition’ but a disease that brings considerable cost to society and health risks.”

Hide

Evidence has shown that obesity is an independent risk factor for severe symptoms from COVID-19. Even after controlling for other health conditions and demographics, a person who is living with obesity is 44% more likely to be critically ill from COVID-19 compared to a healthy weight person, and the risk of dying increases by 27% if have Body Mass Index (BMI) 30-34.9 (hazard ratio 1.27, 95% CI 1.18-1.36), rising to more than twice the risk if have BMI greater than 40 (hazard ratio 2.27, 95% CI 1.99-2.58).

These statistics become even more concerning when one considers the population inequalities that the COVID-19 pandemic has exposed. For some time, we have known that obesity prevalence is much higher in people who live in more deprived areas, and in certain ethnic minority groups. The prevalence of childhood obesity is over twice as high in the most deprived areas relative to the least deprived areas and this gap is widening over time.

There is a clear economic case for preventing and treating obesity. Within the UK National Health Service (NHS), the direct annual costs from treating health complications associated with obesity is over £6bn, with wider costs to society of £27 bn. As well as the serious health consequences, obesity also leads to lower levels of quality of life, increased risk of social stigmatization, depression, low self-esteem and in some children lower levels of educational attainment.

So why is it so difficult to treat and prevent obesity? Obesity is a commonly misunderstood disease. It’s often suggested that it’s due to individuals making ‘bad’ choices over what and how much to eat, and not being physically active enough. This is made worse by media messages about personal responsibility alongside stigmatizing images. Rather, it is a complex condition caused by exposure to the ‘obesogenic’ environment, how we respond to that environment and a complex interaction of genetics, social, environmental and economic circumstances. This means that the policy response is not straightforward, it needs to be multi-faceted with strong leadership coordinating a response from all aspects of the ‘system’.

Across multi-disciplinary academic communities, lowering levels of obesity and in particular reducing population inequalities has been a long-standing priority. Millions of pounds worth of research money has been invested to identify clinical and cost-effective treatment and prevention strategies, yet population rates are still increasing, and inequalities are widening. In recognition of this, the UK Government has published two childhood obesity plans; the first, in August 2016 was widely criticized for not being bold enough with too much emphasis on voluntary action, and the second in June 2018, was improved with tighter controls promised on marketing and advertising of unhealthy foods, and an indication of extending the soft drinks levy to other foods. A prevention green paper and the NHS Long Term Plan also outlined the start of a process to reduce levels of obesity. But many feel this is still not enough, and the Government needs to be much bolder with legislative action to control the food industry

The UK emergency response to COVID-19, like many other countries around the world was to do everything possible to ‘flatten the curve’ with enforced travel restrictions, the shutting of all but essential business, school closures and enforced home working for all but ‘frontline’ workers. A ‘rule of rescue’ strategy was adopted whereby all resources were diverted towards managing COVID-19 cases and preventing deaths.  Various economic support packages were developed costing billions of pounds and sparking fears of an economic crisis and recession like never before. Now that we have passed this ‘first-peak’, and with lockdown restrictions easing, many feel a trade-off between the economy and health, but for the economy to ‘bounce back’ it needs a healthy, productive workforce that is resilient to future health threats.

Now that the emergency response has passed, routine NHS services are re-starting, and thoughts turning towards lessons learned.  COVID-19 has highlighted the urgency of dealing with obesity as no longer a ‘cosmetic condition’ but a disease that brings considerable cost to society and health risks. Health economics can help with identifying cost-effective treatment options from providing dietary and physical activity advice right through to specialist weight management services. Bariatric surgery is a cost-effective treatment option for patients living with obesity, however in the UK only a very small proportion of eligible patients have access. More needs to be done to understand the reasons why and create a health care system that ensures equitable access for all. Analysis of funding structures between local authorities and NHS providers for the delivery of Tier 1 to 4 weight management services needs to be addressed; with consideration of financial incentives for health care professionals to address weight with patients; and a review of the length of funding contracts for weight management services. A comprehensive, bold prevention strategy is key, targeting the food and physical activity environments, and understanding the impact on health inequalities. In light of the COVID-19 pandemic, never before has obesity been such a health and economic priority.

*Professor Emma Frew sits on the strategic council advising the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Obesity.  The views and opinions expressed in this perspective article represent those of the author and not necessarily the views of the APPG-obesity strategic council.

Have your say...

Feedback
  • Nadya isack
    External
    1. At 8:11PM on 09 July 2020, Nadya isack wrote

    Excellent article. Direct and straight to the point

  • Paul Chesworth
    External
    2. At 7:51AM on 10 July 2020, Paul Chesworth wrote

    👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 Great expert knowledge that needs to be shared with society to provide the learning to allow the majority of people to understand that a persons size is not 100% under that persons control, just as any other disease isn’t.

    Provision of treatment and suitable interventions tailored to a persons individual needs is the key to success long term improvements in the UK’s health and ultimate reduction in NHS costs.

  • Rob Wheway
    External
    3. At 8:10PM on 10 July 2020, Rob Wheway wrote

    Except that childhood obesity is not a disease but a predictable result of a poor environment which is also responsible for the deterioration in children's social and mental health.

    For generations most children had access to space in the public realm (the street outside their home) amounting to getting on for half an acre (half football pitch). There they got healthy exercise and social development everyday for free.

    The domination of the car even in side streets has resulted in children being kept indoors because the roads are too dangerous. We know that if zoo animals are kept indoors and stopped from running around by their houses their health deteriorates yet we allow this to happen to our children.

    Link below is to a guardian article I wrote

    https://www.theguardian.com/society/2017/aug/22/fight-child-obesity-let-children-play-outdoors-more-with-friends

    Rob Wheway

    Children's Play Advisory Service

  • Akintomiwa Olamilekan sodiq
    External
    4. At 7:06PM on 12 July 2020, Akintomiwa Olamilekan sodiq wrote

    I went be you student

  • Eric Jones
    External
    5. At 9:29AM on 25 July 2020, Eric Jones wrote

    Hey there, I just found your site, quick question…

    My name’s Eric, I found birmingham.ac.uk after doing a quick search – you showed up near the top of the rankings, so whatever you’re doing for SEO, looks like it’s working well.

    So here’s my question – what happens AFTER someone lands on your site? Anything?

    Research tells us at least 70% of the people who find your site, after a quick once-over, they disappear… forever.

    That means that all the work and effort you put into getting them to show up, goes down the tubes.

    Why would you want all that good work – and the great site you’ve built – go to waste?

    Because the odds are they’ll just skip over calling or even grabbing their phone, leaving you high and dry.

    But here’s a thought… what if you could make it super-simple for someone to raise their hand, say, “okay, let’s talk” without requiring them to even pull their cell phone from their pocket?

    You can – thanks to revolutionary new software that can literally make that first call happen NOW.

    Talk With Web Visitor is a software widget that sits on your site, ready and waiting to capture any visitor’s Name, Email address and Phone Number. It lets you know IMMEDIATELY – so that you can talk to that lead while they’re still there at your site.

    You know, strike when the iron’s hot!

    CLICK HERE http://www.talkwithwebvisitor.com to try out a Live Demo with Talk With Web Visitor now to see exactly how it works.

    When targeting leads, you HAVE to act fast – the difference between contacting someone within 5 minutes versus 30 minutes later is huge – like 100 times better!

    That’s why you should check out our new SMS Text With Lead feature as well… once you’ve captured the phone number of the website visitor, you can automatically kick off a text message (SMS) conversation with them.

    Imagine how powerful this could be – even if they don’t take you up on your offer immediately, you can stay in touch with them using text messages to make new offers, provide links to great content, and build your credibility.

    Just this alone could be a game changer to make your website even more effective.

    Strike when the iron’s hot!

    CLICK HERE http://www.talkwithwebvisitor.com to learn more about everything Talk With Web Visitor can do for your business – you’ll be amazed.

    Thanks and keep up the great work!

    Eric

    PS: Talk With Web Visitor offers a FREE 14 days trial – you could be converting up to 100x more leads immediately!

    It even includes International Long Distance Calling.

    Stop wasting money chasing eyeballs that don’t turn into paying customers.

    CLICK HERE http://www.talkwithwebvisitor.com to try Talk With Web Visitor now.

    If you'd like to unsubscribe click here http://talkwithwebvisitor.com/unsubscribe.aspx?d=birmingham.ac.uk

Add Your Feedback