Passchendaele: why was it fought and why did it fail?

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the University of Birmingham

“The battle ended only when both sides collapsed, exhausted, into the Flanders mud. The generals let it go on too long. They were not, as Taylor thought, blind. But they had developed something like tunnel vision. For them, Passchendaele, like Stalingrad or Sangin in later wars, took on a symbolic significance far greater than its strategic value.”  

Hide

Passchendaele-720px

Of the many beautiful cemeteries cared for around the world by the Commonwealth War Graves Commission, the largest lies on the side of a gentle hill in Belgium. The bodies of nearly 12,000 men lie in Tyne Cot Cemetery, most of them unidentified. Another 35,000 whose bodies were never found are commemorated on a memorial wall at the top of the plot. Look back down the slope: you can see the town of Ypres below, only about five miles away. The men whose ghosts surround you now died fighting for this ground, battling up towards the village of Passchendaele which gives the battle its nickname. More properly known as the Third Battle of Ypres, it is a byword for the futility and horror of war. The famous historian A.J.P. Taylor described it as 'the blindest struggle of a blind war'. Now a hundred years on it is important to consider whether Taylor was right or whether we are ready to form a more balanced opinion.

There is no question that the cost was high, with little to show for it. Of the British, Commonwealth, French and German troops who fought, about half a million became casualties, with perhaps 150,000 men dead. The advance it took the British fourteen weeks to make, you could walk in a couple of hours today. Nevertheless, in the light of recent research, I think it was the right battle, fought in the right place for the right reasons. The problem with this battle was that the British generals fought it in the wrong way. 

After the failure of the Anglo-French offensives of spring 1917, two things were clear. Firstly, doing nothing was not an option. Someone needed to attack the Germans to demonstrate commitment to allies such as America, Italy and, especially, a wavering Russia. Secondly, it was unlikely to be the French who did so. They were beset by unrest both in the army and on the home front. That left the British under Sir Douglas Haig, and the only area they could attack was in Flanders. A successful push might have secured Ypres and the supply ports at Calais and Boulogne, threatening the German rail lines behind the front. Cutting these might have forced German submarines from their bases on the Belgian coast, weakening the U-boat campaign against British shipping. And to wear down the German army could do no harm.

In the event, the British accomplished few of these objectives. The Bolshevik revolution of November 1917 took Russia out of the war. There was no breakthrough, and the German railways remained out of reach. The defenders were pushed back, but the new British positions were precarious and had to be abandoned in spring 1918. The German army had been worn down, but only at a terrible cost in experienced British troops. The battle almost broke both armies. 

Why did the British fail? 

The initial British assault on 31 July was too ambitious and results fell far short of expectations. Attempts throughout August to push on regardless were disjointed and achieved little more. Drier weather in September and new tactics allowed them to begin to grind through the German defences, but casualties remained heavy. In October and November downpours of rain made the battlefield a morass of mud once more. Progress slowed to a crawl. Shivering under cold rain in what little shelter the soldiers could find amid a wasteland of muddy shell craters, it was, as one German general put it, 'no longer life at all. It was just unspeakable suffering.'

The battle ended only when both sides collapsed, exhausted, into the Flanders mud. The generals let it go on too long. They were not, as Taylor thought, blind. But they had developed something like tunnel vision. For them, Passchendaele, like Stalingrad or Sangin in later wars, took on a symbolic significance far greater than its strategic value. The result was that too many brave men like the character in Siegfried Sassoon's poem, 'died in hell—They called it Passchendaele'.

The Centre for War Studies has been at the forefront of research into the First World War for over twenty years. Jonathan's next book, Haig's Enemy: Crown Prince Rupprecht of Bavaria and Germany's War on the Western Front, 1914-1918 will be published by Oxford University Press in March 2018

Have your say...

Feedback
  • George Collings
    External
    1. At 2:04PM on 04 May 2021, George Collings wrote

    WHY, Was Haig such a poor leader ? did he really buy his commission when he commenced . His work after the war will never repay the debt.

  • Jam
    External
    2. At 2:06PM on 23 June 2021, Jam wrote

    There was no breakthrough, and the German railways remained out of reach. The defenders were pushed back, but the new British positions were precarious.

    - https://alisoviejoconcrete.com/

  • sheesh monster
    External
    3. At 11:32PM on 25 October 2021, sheesh monster wrote

    bruh the UK did not fail they won that battle dummy and i dont like how you keep putting comments from historians in i dont care about historians

  • bleepy blorp
    External
    4. At 11:34PM on 25 October 2021, bleepy blorp wrote

    this websits sucks and i hate all the comments except the last one

  • Olympia Wiggins
    External
    5. At 1:03PM on 31 October 2021, Olympia Wiggins wrote

    The first and fundamental benefit is that during the hour of getting schooling, an individual extends his points of view. At first, you get data off an overall sort, which develops your https://topaussiereviews.com/assignmenthelper-review/ insight and makes a reason for additional inside and out an investigation of individual subjects.

  • mike
    External
    6. At 1:37PM on 02 December 2021, mike wrote
  • Drift Hunters
    External
    7. At 2:53AM on 09 December 2021, wrote

    Show all your skills extreme driving and drifting burn rubber on the race track.

  •  online dissertation writing services
    External
    8. At 6:25AM on 10 December 2021, wrote

    We know that battle is not a solution to collapse between two sides or countries. But sometimes some countries couldn't understand this thing. We take the example of Belgium. They lost many of the army and young men in battle. Because of just meaningless war. The battle ended only when both sides collapsed, exhausted, into the Flanders mud. You can also take the example of America japan. But the conclusion is that we should avoid wars and idiot wordings between conversations. If we will not avoid these idiot things we never stop wars. we should always read law dissertation writers' blogs for better knowledge.

  • MarkGuptil
    External
    9. At 11:26AM on 14 December 2021, MarkGuptil wrote

    Well, I got an assignment on this topic in my last year of graduation and I researched too much on the internet and I didn't find some reliable information so I had to take online thesis writing services from ( https://www.phddissertation.co.uk/phd-thesis-help.php ) so they did my assignment and they mentioned some points which I saw there in your article its remind me that days.

  • Tom Tombrownn1975
    External
    10. At 3:24PM on 16 December 2021, Tom Tombrownn1975 wrote

    This is it! I konow that sometimes we all need help with essay and now you have a checne to become the best! Check this website https://handmadewriting.com/ adn be th best! Good luck nad have fun my friend! Enjoy!

  • Sonja Palmer
    External
    11. At 7:27PM on 19 January 2022, Sonja Palmer wrote

    This article is very informative. If you are also searching for such kinds of articles from professional experts then you can visit this website https://www.ihatewritingessays.com/essaypro-com-review. The experts of this website are good professionals and you can trust their services. I am sure you are going to have a great experience here.

  • Rodolfo Bennett
    External
    12. At 7:27PM on 19 January 2022, Rodolfo Bennett wrote

    This article is very informative. If you are also searching for such kinds of articles from professional experts then you can visit this website https://www.ihatewritingessays.com/essaypro-com-review . The experts of this website are good professionals and you can trust their services. I am sure you are going to have a great experience here. Thanks

Add Your Feedback