Advanced materials will not transform industry unless we understand how they transform

By Dr Swaroop Chakraborty, NERC Independent Research Fellow, School of Geography, Earth and Environmental Sciences

water running off a ledge

Advanced materials are expected to help the UK build cleaner industries, strengthen supply chains and create new products. But there is a question we too often ask too late: what happens to these materials once they leave controlled laboratory conditions and encounter water, air or living organisms?

Why this matters for UK industry

This matters because the UK’s Modern Industrial Strategy places advanced materials among the industries expected to drive the future of advanced manufacturing. The Government’s sector plan aims to nearly double annual business investment in advanced manufacturing and identifies advanced materials as one of six industries with particular growth potential. Achieving that ambition will require more than inventing materials with impressive properties. We must also understand whether those properties survive during use, whether performance declines, and what risks may emerge across a material’s whole life.

Presenting at the Nobel forum

I explored this challenge at the Nobel Forum in Stockholm on 6 November 2026, where I had been invited by Professor Bengt Fadeel of Karolinska Institutet’s Institute of Environmental Medicine to speak at the Mini-Symposium on Advanced Materials: Advancing the Safety of Advanced Materials. The forum is best known as the place where the Nobel Assembly selects and announces the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine. Presenting University of Birmingham research there was a privilege, but the value of the meeting lay in bringing materials scientists, environmental researchers, toxicologists and medical researchers into the same conversation.

Metal-organic frameworks and their promise

My talk focused on metal-organic frameworks, known as MOFs. Their structures contain extremely small pores that can be designed to capture particular substances. This makes them promising for applications ranging from removing pollutants from water and recovering valuable minerals to drug delivery. That promise, however, depends on the assumption that the material continues to behave as intended.

Materials are not static

Materials are not static. As they encounter different environments, their pores, surfaces and chemical binding sites can change. A MOF that captures a pollutant efficiently in the laboratory may perform differently in real water. It may retain the pollutant, release it later, become harder to reuse or interact with organisms in unexpected ways. We therefore need to study not only what a material is when it is made, but what it becomes during use and after disposal.

How trace lab studies material behaviour

At TRACE Lab, we combine materials chemistry with environmental nanoscience, toxicology and remediation. Advanced techniques, including synchrotron X-ray spectroscopy and imaging, allow us to see where materials accumulate and how their chemical structures change. We link that evidence with measurements of performance and biological effects. This helps us connect molecular changes with the practical questions that matter to manufacturers, regulators and users: does the material still work, can it be recovered or reused, and is it safe?

Example: UiO-66 and daphnia

One example from our research involved UiO-66, a widely studied MOF. It remained stable in the air and water conditions we tested, but transformed inside Daphnia, small freshwater animals often called water fleas. We also observed reduced reproduction following exposure. This does not mean that all MOFs are unsafe. It shows why conclusions based only on stability in air or water can be incomplete, and why biological interactions need to be assessed alongside technical performance.

Safe and sustainable by design

This is the practical value of a safe and sustainable by design approach. Performance, human health and environmental consequences should be considered from the earliest stages of development, not examined separately once a product is close to market. Finding a weakness early can guide a safer formulation or a more suitable application. It can also reduce the cost of late redesign, strengthen confidence in new technologies and provide better evidence for decisions about manufacture, reuse and disposal.

Turning research into economic value

This evidence will be important if the Industrial Strategy is to turn materials research into durable economic value. The National Materials Innovation Programme, running from 2026 to 2030, is intended to improve coordination and accelerate the adoption of advanced materials across sectors including healthcare, aerospace, automotive and energy. Effective translation will require safety and environmental behaviour to be treated as part of innovation itself. A material that fails too quickly, cannot be recovered or creates avoidable harm is not truly advanced.

The role of universities

Universities have a crucial role here because the challenge crosses traditional boundaries. At Birmingham, our work connects fundamental materials research with environmental analysis and real-world applications such as water treatment and resource recovery. It supports the University’s Birmingham 2030 priorities to deliver research with far-reaching impact, contribute to national and regional priorities, build international partnerships and use research to advance sustainability.

Opportunities for Birmingham and the West Midlands

For Birmingham and the West Midlands, this creates opportunities to support cleaner manufacturing, more circular use of resources and collaboration between researchers and businesses developing the next generation of materials. My discussions in Stockholm with Avi Schroeder, Radek Zbořil, Peter Wick, Lang Tran, Jasreen Kaur, Andi Alijagic and Tomáš Malina opened further possibilities for combining expertise in materials science, medicine and safety assessment. International collaboration of this kind can help us build the robust evidence base that responsible innovation requires.

What's next?

The opportunity offered by advanced materials is substantial. To realise it, we need to stop treating performance, safety and sustainability as competing demands. Understanding how materials transform gives us the knowledge to design them better, regulate them more intelligently and use them with greater confidence. That is how advanced materials can deliver not just scientific novelty, but lasting benefits for industry, society and the environment.