IRiS Working Paper Series: Reimagining society in the age of superdiversity
IRiS is dedicated to being at the cutting edge of research into superdiversity. To support this commitment we regularly publish working papers that seek to address emerging areas of interest in the field. By encouraging new research we continue to promote new discussion and the most up-to-date analysis. The series has enabled new approaches to policy and service delivery across health services, migrant rights, refugee integration and social housing.
The series is edited by IRiS Deputy Director Dr Nando Sigona and associate member Dr Aleksandra Kozlowska and is open for proposals from researchers, policy makers and practitioners. For queries and proposals, please email: firstname.lastname@example.org.
List of Working Papers
IRiS Working Paper 31 (2019) [PDF]
Sexual and gender-based violence and refugees: The impacts of and on integration domains
By Jenny Phillimore, Sandra Pertek, and Lailah Alidu
In considering the state of knowledge around sexual violence and war Skjelsbaek notes the reluctance of researchers to “look into how this crime affects the victims” (2001:212). Given the prevalence of SGBV across the refugee journey, experiences need to be conceptualised as an ongoing and multi-faceted experience of trauma, with both immediate and long-term consequences. Pulling together the piecemeal evidence in the literature on SGBV, we describe distal impacts of SGBV on integration, wherein traumatic but largely sporadic events impact on integration. We also describe the proximal impacts of integration domains on SGBV survivors’ lives, whereby refugees’ exposure to, and ability to recover from, SGBV is shaped by experience within the integration domains. We conclude that the experience of SGBV can hamper survivors’ attempts to resettle and integrate into a new life through a number of distal impacts on and proximal impacts of integration, and embedded within these structural inequalities.
IRiS Working Paper 30 (2019) [PDF]
What responses, approaches to treatment, and other supports are effective in assisting refugees who have experienced sexual and gender-based violence?
By Karen Block, Hala Nasr, Cathy Vaughan and Sara Alsaraf
Violence, insecurity, persecution, and human rights violations have led to the forced displacement of an estimated 68.5 million people as of 2018 (UNHCR, 2018a). Of those 68.5 million, 25.4 million are refugees - the highest number ever recorded; 3.1 million are asylum seekers; and 40 million are internally displaced (UNHCR, 2018a). Humanitarian emergencies exacerbate the unequal power relations and structural inequalities that underpin the sexual and gender-based violence (SGBV) experienced by girls and women, as well as boys and men (UNOCHA, 2016). In some humanitarian emergencies, more than 70 percent of women have experienced gender-based violence and an estimated one in five displaced women will experience sexual violence (UN Women, 2017). Conflictrelated sexual violence against men and boys has been documented around the world, though data to determine prevalence are limited (Solangon & Patel, 2012). Following displacement, and even after permanent resettlement, different kinds of insecurity such as breakdown of family and community networks, shifting gender roles, and limited access to resources can also increase the risk of SGBV. Responses to SGBV need to adapt to varying contexts and needs across the refugee journey, however there is no comprehensive evidence base for understanding how these needs evolve at different points for people on the move. This working paper is a critical overview of the current state of knowledge on responsesto SGBV for refugees, asylum seekers and internally displaced persons across all stages of the refugee journey.
IRiS Working Paper 29 (2019) [PDF]
Monitoring and reporting incidents of sexual and gender-based violence across the refugee journey
By Siân Thomas, Hoayda Darkal and Lisa Goodson
This paper considers the way in which incidents of sexual and gender-based violence (SGBV) have been recorded across the refugee journey to date. It takes a detailed look at current mechanisms used to record and monitor instances of SGBV and assesses the strengths and weaknesses of current systems. The barriers hindering the accurate recording of SGBV cases are discussed in relation to gendercultural norms, political, and practical dilemmas associated with self-reporting SGBV incidences. The importance and utility of developing more robust and systematic monitoring systems are finally considered alongside a series of practical and actionable recommendations on how to improve the monitoring of SGBV across the refugee journey.
IRiS Working Paper 28 (2019) [PDF]
Defining Sexual and Gender-Based Violence in the Refugee Context
By Andrew Simon-Butler and Professor Bernadette McSherry
This working paper provides an overview of how key terms relating to SGBV have been defined and how these terms may apply in the refugee context. It examines how a broad definition of SGBV has been used to explore current practices in conflict settings, with particular focus on the current conflict in Syria. The international community’s approach to SGBV is examined, with attention paid to definitions in Conventions and under international law. Finally, what gender means in the context of SGBV and the resulting debates about who should be the primary focus of humanitarian intervention are discussed.
IRiS Working Paper 27 (2019) [PDF]
What is the nature of SGBV?
By Saime Ozcurumez, Hannah Bradby and Selin Akyuz
Based on a review of scholarly work and reports, this working paper analyzes different facets of sexual and gender based violence (SGBV) by revealing the contraints that potentially cause gendered presumptions. Reviewing the conceptualization of SGBV in the literature dealing with gender and the governance of international migration not only juxtaposes existing approaches to understanding SGBV and its defining parameters but also presents how vulnerabilities, insecurities and victimization are presumed to intersect with that violence. This framework enables a critical analysis by indicating the theoretical and empirical gaps, which are enumerated. The final part of the paper proposes some notes for further research and asserts the need to understand the nature of SGBV from the perspective of refugees themselves, rather than from the perspective of humanitarian and/or medical professionals providing refugees with services. The view of SGBV violence as mainly consisting in physical violence against non-European women who lack agency, is juxtaposed with the absence of gender as an overt ground for protection under the Refugee convention.
IRiS Working Paper 26 (2018) [PDF]
Welfare bricolage in different health regimes: motivations, logics and tactics
By Jenny Phillimore, Hannah Bradby, Michi Knecht, Beatriz Padilla and Simon Pemberton
This paper provides and overview of the findings from interviews with residents in four different European cities. It examines the actions that individuals take, in order to address a health concern. The paper outlines the different courses of action that individuals take including remaining within the public health system, bricolaging within that system, adding to the system, using entirely alternative systems or using no resources whatsoever. The ways in which they combine resources across different sectors and international borders is discussed alongside the use of virtual and social resources.
IRiS Working Paper 25 (2018) [PDF]
Pathways of Settlement among Recent Migrants in Super-diverse Areas
By Susanne Wessendorf
This report summarizes the main findings of the research into how new migrants find ways to settle when they do not have existing support structures to ‘dock onto’. It first sets out the nature of the study and defines the notion of pioneer migrants, before moving on to introduce the research sites and methodology. The remainder of the report addresses the findings of the project, focussing on the most relevant issues around settlement such as legal status and integration into the labour market, but also including the role of social relations when settling in a new place
IRiS Working Paper 24 (2018) [PDF]
Welfare Bricolage in Portuguese Service Providers: from challenges to strategies 2017By Beatriz Padilla, Simone Castellani, Vera Rodrigues and Jessica Lopes
The Welfare Bricolage project (UPWEB) will reconceptualise welfare theory through responding to the question of how all residents living in superdiverse neighbourhoods put together their healthcare. Increasing population complexity, heterogeneity and pace of change under globalisation has provoked a need to rethink welfare design, alongside issues of engagement, approachability and effectiveness. This report focusses on the welfare bricolage of residents in Lisbon, Portugal, highlighting how they access healthcare and the barriers they face within the healthcare system.
IRiS Working Paper 23 (2017) [PDF]
Logics of Welfare Bricolage among UK Service Providers
By Professor Simon Pemberton and Dr Lucy Doos
This working paper focuses on the challenges faced by health care providers in delivering services in two superdiverse neighbourhoods (Handsworth and Edgbaston) in Birmingham, UK. The paper explores the nature of the local population / clients living in such areas and the types of health problems that providers seek to address. The degree to which neighbourhood superdiversity has shaped the nature of provision is explored, as well as challenges to service delivery such as language, culture and traditions, transience and transnational health seeking. Through drawing on the concept of ‘bricolage’, the paper subsequently highlights the strategies that providers have developed to overcome service delivery challenges in rapidly changing and highly complex superdiverse environments.
IRiS Working Paper 22 (2017) [PDF]
Typologies and logics of welfare bricolage in Portugal: Lisbon case study (UPWEB)
By Beatriz Padilla, Vera Rodrigues and Tiago Chaves
This Working Paper forms part of the UPWEB research project, examining welfare theory through responding to the question of how residents in superdiverse areas put together their welfare. This process known as "bricolaging" is examined across two neighbourhoods in Lisbon (Portugal), identifying how residents bricolage and the barriers and opportuntites they face as a result.
IRiS Working Paper 21 (2017) [PDF]
Typologies and logics of welfare bricolage in Sweden: Uppsala case study (UPWEB)
By Sarah Hamed and Hannah Bradby
This Working Paper forms part of the UPWEB research project, examining welfare theory through responding to the question of how residents in superdiverse areas put together their welfare. This process known as "bricolaging" is examined across two towns in Uppsala (Sweden), identifying how residents bricolage and the barriers and opportuntites they face as a result.
IRiS Working Paper 20 (2017) [PDF]
European denizens: The political participation of UK based EU citizens at the EU referendum
By Monika Bozhinoska
In June 2016 the UK held a referendum on whether to stay or leave the EU. EU citizens living in the UK, irrespective of how long had they spent in the UK, were not eligible to vote. This study uses the referendum as a case to analyse the ethnic nationalism model of state membership in relation to EU citizenship. It focuses on how EU residents experienced the referendum campaign and the exclusion from referendum voting. Specifically, it investigates the EU citizens’ perception of their political integration in the state, their national identities and feeling of membership, as well as their political engagement in the EU referendum. The study draws on semi-structured in-depth interviews with EU citizens who lived in the UK for at least 5 years and do not have British citizenship.
IRiS Working Paper 19 (2017) [PDF]
Typologies and logics of welfare bricolage in the UK
By Simon Pemberton and Arshad Isakjee
This working paper focuses on identifying the different types and rationales for bricolage being undertaken by residents in two superdiverse neighbourhoods (Handsworth and Edgbaston) in Birmingham, UK. It explores how residents may bricolage to i) achieve health and well-being; and ii) to address a specific health concern. In particular, actions and resources that individuals used to address a health concern are discussed, as well as the reasons why individuals engaged in bricolage activities. These include a lack of confidence in formal (NHS) provision, to secure more culturally appropriate care, to seek reassurance and to supplement formal provision. A number of barriers / impediments to bricolage are also highlighted. The report concludes by setting out the different types of bricolage in evidence in the case study areas.
IRiS Working Paper 18 (2017) [PDF]
Welfare state regimes: a literature review
By Arshad Isakjee
This literature review seeks to position the UPWEB research project in relation to discourses on welfare regimes. The UPWEB project is exploring the workings of healthcare in four European states with different types of welfare governance. Any comparison between these case-studies depends on an analysis of welfare regimes themselves, their construction, their validity and applicability.
IRiS Working Paper 17 (2017) [PDF]
Super-diversity and the social production of space in a small Catalan town
By Martin Lundsteen
Taking its point of departure in the case of Salt, a small Catalan town located next to Girona, this paper analyses the everyday negotiation of the emerging ‘super-diverse’ reality outside the metropolis, yielding a specific focus to space. Employing the conceptual distinction developed by Setha Low between social production and social construction of space, recent historical developments in this rural-urban locality are analysed, accounting for the contested understandings of space and belonging.
IRiS WP 16-2017 [PDF]
Messaging in the Midlands: Exploring digital literacy repertoires in a superdiverse region
By Caroline Tagg and Esther Asprey
This paper explores how individuals and communities living or working in the West Midlands exploit practices of ‘translanguaging’ in the maintenance of intimate relationships – that is, how they draw on features from various local (and far-flung) dialects, languages, styles, scripts and registers as expressive resources.
IRiS WP 15-2016 [PDF]
Adaptation of Health Services to Diversity: An overview of approaches
By Jenny Phillimore with Franziska Klaas, Beatriz Padilla, Sonia Hernández-Plaza and Vera Rodrigues
This review focuses upon the literature that describes or examines the ways in which health services
have been reconfigured (or not) in light of changing demographics, namely the emergence of
IRiS WP 14-2016 [PDF]
Bricolage: potential as a conceptual tool for understanding access to welfare in superdiverse neighbourhoods
By Jenny Phillimore, Rachel Humphries, Franziska Klaas and Michi Knecht
The scientific and policy challenges emerging from the complexity associated with delivering welfare in an era of superdiversity have been noted... as providers struggle to communicate with, understand and meet the needs of service users.
IRiS WP 13-2016 [PDF]
Locality, neighbourhood and health: a literature review
By Simon Pemberton and Rachel Humphris
Traditionally, the study of place in public health, epidemiology, medical geography and medical sociology has been neglected. However, over time there has been increasing recognition of the importance of place in shaping health.
IRiS WP 12-2016 [PDF]
Dimensions of Diversity: Terminology in health research
by Hannah Bradby and Tilman Brand
This short review considers how ‘ethnicity’ and ‘superdiversity’ are used alongside ‘diversity’ in health research in a sample of recent journal articles.
IRiS WP 11-2015 [PDF]
Challenging the destitution policy: Civil society organisations supporting destitute migrants
by Adrian Randall
This IRiS Working Paper reviews changes in the law on immigration and asylum affecting the support available to asylum seekers. In particular, the Asylum and Immigration Act 1996 and successor legislation has made refused asylum seekers destitute by terminating support.
IRiS WP 10-2015 [PDF]
Call for consistent incorporation of superdiversity considerations in the European Court of Human Rights' (non-discrimination) jurisprudence
by Kristin Henrard
Super-diversity may not yet be a term of art in the field of fundamental rights, courts are undoubtedly confronted with cases that de facto concern super-diversity, understood here as referring to various layers of ethnic population diversity and the related differential rights of the distinctive groups.
IRiS WP 9-2015 [PDF]
'All the people speak bad English’: Coping with language differences in a super-diverse context
by Susanne Wessendorf
In recent years, there has been a surge in studies on immigration-related diversity and, more specifically, super-diversity. This paper gives an overview of recent academic debates on encounters in super-diverse urban contexts, drawing on theories which have focused on interactional principles in such urban spaces.
IRiS WP 8-2015 [PDF]
Superdiverse Britain and new migrant enterprises
by Trevor Jones, Monder Ram, Yaojun Li, Paul Edwards and Maria Villares
Diversity has been framed either as positive for economic dynamism and prosperity in British urban spaces, contributing to greater competitiveness, attractiveness of cosmopolitan lifestyle as well as the growth of a variety of migrant enterprises, or as having a negative impact on average wages, job availability and welfare provision.
IRiS WP 7-2015 [PDF]
Migration and integration, A local and experiential perspective
by Gary Craig
This working paper was originally produced for the KING programme, an interdisciplinary and international programme of research funded by the EU, exploring the factors facilitating or impeding the integration of migrants.
IRiS WP 6-2015 [PDF]
Social networks, social capital and migrant integration at local level - European literature review
by Marta Kindler with Vasselina Ratcheva and Maria Piechowska
This Working Paper examines the state of knowledge concerning the relationships between social networks, social capital and migrant integration at local level.
IRiS WP 5-2015 [PDF]
The challenges of superdiversity for social housing
by Gail Walters
The changing nature of many urban communities in the UK is providing challenges to traditional models of managing social housing.
IRiS WP 4-2014 [PDF]
Causes and experiences of poverty among economic migrants in the UK
by Simon Pemberton, Jenny Phillimore and David Robinson
Poverty is an important driver of migration. Many people migrate to escape poverty.
IRiS WP 3-2014 [PDF]
Integration practice in the European Union. Initiatives and innovations by institutions and civil society
by Rachel Humphris
This paper reviews integration practices undertaken by civil society and local institutions across European Member States that have been identified as...
IRiS WP 2-2014 [PDF]
Researching social relations in super-diverse neighbourhoods. Mapping the field by Susanne Wessendorf
There has been a surge in studies on immigration-related diversity and, more specifically, superdiversity...
IRiS WP 1-2014 [PDF]
Poverty among refugees and asylum seekers in the UK. An evidence and policy review
by Jennifer Allsopp, Nando Sigona and Jenny Phillimore
This WP review focuses on the experiences of poverty among refugees, asylum seekers and refused asylum seekers, including women.