Are we having a Plastic Moment?

views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the University of Birmingham

“Plastics will continue to stick around (although probably not forever): the plastic ‘problem’ has not gone away.”


With the challenges, traumas and tensions that have been posed by the COVID-19 pandemic, one might be forgiven for thinking that other, once pressing issues, have been set aside. However, some scientists have argued that threats such as climate change may pose a bigger threat to human health than Coronavirus. Issues such as climate change, air pollution and plastic pollution have not disappeared. Nonetheless, the relative and shifting prominence of these different debates indicates how they can be felt as moments in human history.

Plastics represent a case in point. Following the broadcast of the final episode of the BBC’s Blue Planet II in December 2017, we – in the UK at least – ‘had a moment’. Despite years of patient scientific work and environmental advocacy, it suddenly dawned upon us that the ‘plastic problem’ was far larger and more pervasive than we had realised. We all knew that plastics littering our streets and countryside looked ugly; and many of us knew that they could be harmful to wildlife. But who knew that there were microplastics in bottled water (often more than in most tapwaters)i? Or that plastics were congealing in (largely invisible) oceanic vorticesii? Or that once-molten plastics have combined with rock, sand and organic matter to create new materials, known as ‘plastiglomerates’?

However, thinking back to the couple of years before COVID-19, it was apparent that our ‘plastic moment’ was about more than the widespread acquisition of knowledge about plastics. For, this moment was one that we felt. The media fall-out from Blue Planet II indicated how viewers responded emotively to the programme, apparently ‘heartbroken’ at plastics’ effects on marine environments. Soon afterwards, we were being asked to make all kinds of changes to our lifestyles – from our (re)use of plastic bags, to our consideration of plastic alternatives for all manner of everyday objects. This was not only a moment in which our relationships with plastics were being recalibrated, but in which our own feelings, actions and daily habits were changing – being rendered plastic.

However, it is useful to zoom out to consider plastics in their wider historical, social and geographical contexts.

Firstly, there is ongoing debate about whether plastics form part of human impacts on the earth that are so great that they constitute a new geological epoch: the Anthropocene. Within this story, plastics are but a blip (and an even smaller one when seen in the context of deep geological time). They are but a moment.

Secondly, however, plastics will stick around: whilst we humans have only been so tangled-up with (synthetic) plastics for about a century, some plastics will potentially remain in the earth’s hydrological, geological and ecological systems for millennia.

Thirdly, and turning the attention back to a more human timescale, the effects of plastics vary dramatically depending on who you are and where you live. ‘Our’ plastic moment divides as much as it unifies humans. For many of us, the health impacts of ingesting plastics, at least through drinking water, appear – on the latest medical evidence – to be negligible compared with other risks. Yet for those handling plastics – in recycling plants in countries like China, for instance – the long-term effects of exposure to plasticisers could be detrimental (ranging from mental ill-health to male infertilityiii). Sticking with China, some critical race scholars have also argued that the intensification of attention to plastics in our plastic moment has in some cases been a conduit for racism – with ‘blame’ for the production of mass-produced, plastic items such as toys sometimes being levelled at Chinaiv. In other contexts again, though – not least in the disposable equipment used in the fight against COVID-19 – plastics might be viewed less critically.

Even if COVID-19 has exposed our obsession with plastics as in many ways momentary, this moment will have long-lasting effects that are patterned in different ways, for different people, in different places. Plastics will continue to stick around (although probably not forever): the plastic ‘problem’ has not gone away. Yet the effects of our recent ‘plastic moment’ on our attempts to resolve how exactly we should relate to plastics in the future require further consideration if we are to truly learn how to live (better) with plastics.

iNovotna K, Cermakova L, Pivokonska L, Cajthaml T and Pivokonsky M (2019) Microplastics in drinking water treatment–Current knowledge and research needs. Science of the Total Environment, 667: 730-740.

iiLiboiron M (2016) Redefining pollution and action: The matter of plastics. Journal of Material Culture 21: 87-110.

iiiDavis H (2015) Life & death in the Anthropocene: A short history of plastic. Art in the anthropocene: Encounters among aesthetics, politics, environments and epistemologies, pp.347-358.

ivHuang M (2017) Ecologies of entanglement in the great pacific garbage patch. Journal of Asian American Studies 20: 95-117.

 vFor more details, see Kraftl, P. (2020) After Childhood: re-thinking environment, materiality and media in children's lives. London: Routledge.

Have your say...

  • Kenn Winter
    1. At 2:27PM on 16 August 2020, Kenn Winter wrote

    No Pictures ?!

    A picture saves / says a thousand words - & is the key " hook " for popular readership.

  • Arec Jone
    2. At 12:21PM on 14 October 2021, Arec Jone wrote

    climate change is happening and is affecting us all. We depend on the land for food and shelter, and when it changes, we suffer. I will visit website to get an essay written on this topic. Every year in Ethiopia a million people die from a lack of water. As glaciers in the north melt, there will be even less water for

  • Arno Savard
    3. At 8:32AM on 16 November 2021, Arno Savard wrote

    Play casino games in demo mode, learn about the most profitable slots and check out practical guides written by Casinority experts This review site offers unbiased ratings and detailed overviews of the most reputable casino content on the web. Learn all you need, and win big today.

  • Max Kush
    4. At 1:18PM on 13 December 2021, Max Kush wrote

    Considering all the pros and cons of a certain broker by yourself might be too exhausting, so we have already done it for you. We have noted all the specific requirements of different kinds of traders based on numerous criteria. So whether it is your first day as a trader, or you have already been in the business for years, our materials will be equally useful for you. Just scroll the website and find your own best forex broker.

  • Larry Morgan
    5. At 11:10AM on 11 January 2022, Larry Morgan wrote

    It's a fantastic piece of writing that captures all of the nuances of superb writing. Only professional essay writers are capable of completing such a task. However, if you want such high-quality coursework help, contact Assignment Help Service. Experts at the firm provide the greatest dissertation help online.


  • Oliver jake
    6. At 10:06AM on 20 January 2022, Oliver jake wrote

    I like the valuable information you provide in your blog. I’m quite certain I will learn lots of new stuff right here!

Add Your Feedback